Monday 10 February 2014

An Article about "Registration of Property"




All documents do not require registration compulsorily. The Transfer of Property Act, 1882 and the Indian Registration Act, 1908 have made registration of certain documents compulsory while in respect of certain other documents it is optional.

According to Section 17 of the Indian Registration Act, 1908 registration of documents is compulsory if they relate to an immovable property.  Similarly, Section 54 of Transfer of Property Act 1882, stipulates that sale of immovable property the value of which is one hundred rupees or more should be registered. Since no immovable property is available for rupees one hundred or less than rupees one hundred, implicitly all sale deeds of immovable property need compulsory registration.

Most of the instruments dealing with the immovable property for  creating, declaring, assigning, limiting or extinguishing any right, title or interest in  the property require compulsory registration, as enumerated under theIndian Registration Act, 1908. For executing an instrument, the first and the foremost aspect to be considered is the nature of the right intended to be transferred. If the document falls within the category of the documents whichwarrants compulsory registration, any avoidance of registration of such document would invalidate the document itself.  For documents which require mandatory registration certain proceduresare prescribed.


Under Section 23 of the Registration Act, subject to certain exceptions, any document other than a Will has to be presented for registration within four months from the date of its execution.  Execution means signing of the document. It is not uncommon that the date of execution and the date of registration may differ. For the non-testamentary documents such as Sale Deed, Gift Deed, Mortgage Deed, etc, the time limit within which the document has to be registered is four months from the date of execution. Decrees drawn in terms of Compromise Petition wherein shares of the parties are allotted by metes and bounds require registration. Even for registration of the court decree, four months time limit is stipulated under the Act. 

If the document is executed by all or any of the parties residing abroad, the same canbe accepted for registration within four months from the date of receipt of thedocument in India. In case of doubt as to the validity of registration, the document may be re-registered within four months from the date when it is noticed that the registration is invalid or of doubtful validity. Where a document is executed by several persons at different times, it should be presented within four months from the date of the latest execution for registration. If a document is not presented for registration within the prescribed period of four months and the delay in presentation of the document does not exceed a further period of four months, then the parties can apply to the Registrar for registration of the document who may direct, upon payment of  fine not exceeding ten times the actual registration fees, for registration of such a document [Sec.25].

A document relating to an immovable property can be executed out of India and later it can be presented for registration in India.  As per section 26 of the Registration Act, 1908, if a document purporting to have been executed by all or any of the parties out of India is presented within the prescribed period of time for registration, the Registering Officer may, on payment of proper registration fee accept such document for registration if he is satisfied that the instrument was executed out of India and the instrument has been presented for registration within four months after its arrival in India.


Fees charged for the registration or searching the register are prescribed by State Governments through Notifications.


In case of Testamentary instrument, that is, Will, registration is optional and time limit is not prescribed. It can be registered any time before the death of the Testator. How-ever, it is advisa-ble to register the same as soon as possible in order to avoid disputes about the genuineness of its execution. In case of registration of Will, the same may be presented by the Testator during his life time and after his death, by the beneficiary or the administrator, for registration. A Will may be deposited with the Sub-Registrar in a sealed cover and such deposit may be done through an agent. After the death of the Testator, the sealed envelope will be opened and the contents recorded in the relevant register maintained in the Sub-Registrar's Office. The Original copy of the 'Will' will be in the custody of the Sub-Registrar.


Generally documents have to be presented for registration only at the Sub-Registrar's office within whose jurisdiction the immovable property is situated. However, in certain exceptional cases, documents may be presented for registration with the Registrar who has been conferred with the power to register the documents. In fact, Sub-Registrars have been vested with the special power to register the document at the residence or office of the executant or to accept deposit of Will.


Documents which require mandatory registration have to be presented in the concerned Sub-Registrar Office for registration by the executant or person claiming under the Decree. However, in certain cases, the representatives of the Executant,duly authorized under Power of Attorney, can also execute the same on behalf of the Executant. A power of Attorney holder can execute the document, representing the Principal only if an authority has been vested in him under Power of Attorney, which is authenticated by the Registering authority within whose jurisdiction the Principal resides. 

If the Principal does not reside in India, then the Power of Attorney should be executed before and authenticated by a Notary Public or any Court, Judge, Magistrate, Indian Consul or Vice-Consul or the Representative of Central Government in that country and the same is required to be presented with the concerned registrar in India with in a period of three months of its receipt in India. When a document has been executed by more than one executant and after execution of the same, one of the executants refrain from attending the concerned Sub-Registrar's Office for registration, then the remaining executants can compel attendance of the executant reluctant to be present before the registering authority through the process of law.


The Registering Officer is empowered under sec. 34 of the Registration Act to enquire whether or not the person is the same by whom it purports to have been executed such a document.  He may insist on production of proof for his identity and in case any person is appearing as a representative or agent, the Registrar may ask for relevant documents to show that the agent or representative has the right to appear on behalf of his principal.    

Effect of non-registration

What would be the repercussion if a document which requires  compulsory registration  is not registered? Section 49 of IndianRegistration Act deals with this situation. It states clearly that such un-registered documents do not convey to the transferee a legally valid title and such documents are not admitted as evidence for any transaction affecting the property referred to in the document. However, there is an exception provided in the Act. The unregistered documents may be admitted as evidence in a suit for specific performance under Specific Relief Act or in any other related transaction, not required to be effected under a registered instrument.

Documents are mainly registered for conservation of evidence, assurance of title, and to help an intending purchaser to know if the title deeds of a particular property have been deposited with any financial institution or person for purpose of obtaining loan or advance against security of the property. Registration of documents acts as notice to the public and to protect oneself against the likely fraud. Therefore, it is advisable to register all documents connected with the immovable property irrespective of whether the registration is compulsory or not as it creates a permanent record of event which are reflected in encumbrance certificates. 


Friday 7 February 2014

An Article about "Compulsorily registerable property documents"


All documents do not require registration compulsorily. The Transfer of Property Act, 1882 and the Indian Registration Act, 1908 have made registration of certain documents compulsory while in respect of certain other documents it is optional.

According to section 17 of the Indian Registration Act, 1908 registration of documents .Js compulsory if they relate to an immovable property. Similarly, Section 54 of Transfer of Property Act 1882, stipulates that sale of immovable property the value of which is one hundred rupees or more should be registered. Since no immovable property is available for rupees one hundred or less than 2. rupees one hundred, implicitly all sale deeds of immovable property need compulsory registration.

Section 17(1) of Indian Registration Act 1902, deals with the documents which require registration compulsorily. They include:

Gift is given by the donor to the donee without any monetary consideration, but only in consideration of love and affection the donor has towards the donee. Therefore, gift deeds transferring immovable property of the value of Rs.I00/- and above need registration.

2. Other non-testamentary documents which purport to create, assign, limit or extinguish the right, title and interest in immovable property the value of which is more than one hundred rupees need registration.

3. All non-testamentary documents which acknowledge the receipt or payment of any consideration on account of the transactions pertaining to the creation of any right, title, interest in the immovable property need registration.

All non-testamentary documents transferring or assigning any decree or order, award of a court, which affect the right, title and interest in immovable property the value of which is one hundred rupees and above need registration The documents may create, extinguish, assign, declare, limit or restrict the right, title and interest in the immovable property for the present or future, but if the value of such immovable property is one hundred rupees or more, the deed needs to be registered.

Though all types of mortgages need registration, mortgage created by depositing of title deeds, known as equitable mortgage, is not compulsorily registerable. Mostly, banks and financial institutions use this mode of mortgage. However, memorandum of deposit of title deed needs registration.

Section 107 of Transfer of Property Act 1882, prescribes that lease of immovable property from "year to year" or for any term exceeding one year or reserving a yearly rent must be done only by a registered instrument. The phrase from 'year to year', refers to a continuous lease from year to year, that is, where the landlord has no option to terminate the lease at the end of the year without notice. 

Similarly the phrase, "reserving yearly rents" means that the lease has no definite period, but the annual rent is determined. The word "yearly" means that the lease should run year after year or at least more than a year. In general, any lease in excess of one year and above should be registered.

There are certain documents registration of which is optional. Section 18 of the Indian Registration Act, 1908 lays down the instruments of which registration is optional. They include: 

a] Instruments relating to transfer of an immovable property, the value of which is less than rupees one hundred;
b] Lease of an immovable property for a term not exceeding one year;
c] Wills
d] Deed of gift of property valued at less than Rs.100/-

Time limit for registration: 

Under Section 23 of the Registration Act, subject to certain exceptions, any document other than a will has to be presented for registration within four months from the date of its execution. Execution means signing of the document.

If a document is not presented for registration within the prescribed period of four months and the delay in presentation of the document does not exceed a further period of four months, then the parties can apply to the Registrar for registration of the document who may direct, upon payment of a fine not exceeding ten times the actual registration fees, for registration of such a document.

A document relating to an immovable property can be executed out of India and later it can be presented for registration in India. As per section 26 of the Registration Act, 1908, if a document purporting to have been executed by all or any of the parties out of India is presented for registration within the prescribed period of time, the Registering Officer may, on payment of proper registration fee accept such document for registration if he is satisfied that the instrument was executed out side India and the instrument has been presented for registration within four months after its arrival in India.  

The Registering Officer is empowered under sec. 34 of the Registration Act to enquire whether or not the person is the same by whom it purports to have been executed such a document. He may insist on production of proof for his identity and in case any person is appearing as a representative or agent, the Registrar may ask for relevant documents to show that the agent or representative has the right to appear on behalf of his principal. 

What would be the repercussion if a document which is compulsorily registerable is not registered?

Section 49 of Indian Registration Act deals with this situation. It states clearly that such un-registered documents do not convey to the transferee a legally valid title and such documents are not admitted as evidence for any transaction affecting the property referred to in the document. However, there is an exception provided in the Act. The unregistered documents may be admitted as evidence in a suit for specific performance under Specific Relief Act.

Documents are mainly registered for conservation of evidence, assurance of title, and to help an intending purchaser to know if the title deeds of a particular property have been deposited with any financial institution or person for purpose of obtaining loan or advance against security of the property.

Registration of documents acts as notice to the public and to protect themselves against the likely fraud. Therefore, it is advisable to register all documents connected with the immovable property irrespective of whether the registration is compulsory or not as it creates a permanent record of event which are reflected in encumbrance certificates.

As registered documents have higher value of evidence than unregistered documents it is always beneficial to you if you get all your property documents registered within the stipulated period irrespective of the fact that such registration is mandatory or not.

Thursday 6 February 2014

An Article about "Impracticable Stamp Duty on Joint Development Agreement"


The words "Joint Venture" is described as "a business activity by two or more people or companies working together". Many times an individual may own some land, but may not have funds to fully exploit it. Similarly a builder/developer who has resource may need some land to employ his resource profitably. For vertical development of land which comprises of a number of flats lot of money, manpower and expertise are necessary all of which an individual cannot possess. More over, unlike in thecase of construction of independent house, the group housing or construction ofapartments is more complicated. It requires approval from various agencies like water supply board, sanitary department, electric power supply board, Airport Authorities, Pollution Control Board, Survey Department, Telephone Department, etc. The group housing project also has to get through a much strictercompliance of procedure for obtaining project loans from the banks.

Thus, Joint Development Agreements are entered into by the land owners and the developers for mutual benefit and for the development of theproperty to the best advantage of both the parties. Joint Development venture is an activity of bring together the land of the land owner and the talent and expertise of the developer for creation of an asset called the apartment building. While the land owners possess certain land which is fit for development, the Developer has all the resource and talent to develop the land for construction of apartment building. 

He has technical skill, financial resource,capable of getting the land conversion from agriculture to non-agricultural residential purposes, capacity to get layout and plan approval from the competent authority, select the work force and drive them to achieve his goal. Thus, when both the land owner and the developer enter into development agreement, they would generally put forth all the relevant clauses requiring for development of the land including sharing ratio. But at that stage, the developer would not definitely calculate the financial implications involved in such ventures Based on this joint development agreement, the developer proceeds to chalk out the fine blue print of the development and takes steps for obtainingloan from the banks or financial institutions. 

Only upon getting the approval of the competent authority regarding land conversion, layout approval and building plan sanction the developer would take steps for ascertaining the costof construction, or development, selection, contractors; required work force etc. The cost of units at which the developer intends to sell the individualapartment units to the prospective purchasers could be ascertained only when the final estimated figure of expenditure on men and material are ascertained by the developer which estimation at any cost cannot be done at the time ofentering into joint development agreement.

Neither the land owner nor the developer would know at the timeof entering into joint development agreement, the estimated court of construction or the development or the cost at which they would like to sell the apartment units to the prospective buyers and it would be premature to delve upon it atthat stage.

Under this Amendment Act, amendment to Art.S (f) has introduced in addition to amendments in certain sections and other Articles. Article 5 deals with agreement or [its records or] memorandum of an agreement. Article 5(t) deals with the agreements relating to construction or development or sale of an immovable property, including a multi-unit house or building or unit of apartment or flat or portion of a multi-storied building by a person having a stipulation that after construction or development, such property shall be held jointly or severally by that person and the owner or lessee of such property, or that it shall be sold jointly or severally by them or that a part of it shall be held jointly or severally by them and the remaining part thereof shall be sold jointly or severally by them. The stamp duty prescribed under the amended actis under:

"One rupee for everyone hundred rupees or part thereof on the market value of the property or the estimated cost of construction or proposed construction or development or proposed development of the property, which is the subject matter of such transfer under the agreement in accordance with the provisions of sec.28 of the Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957) or on the considerationfor such transfer, whichever is higher. 

A reading of this amended article would go to that the stampduty is payable in respect of joint " development agreements or in respect of sale of multi-unit house or unit of apartment or flat etc., shall be at one rupee for every one hundred rupees or part thereof of the highest of the value of any one of the following:


It would be practically difficult and almost impossible to arrive at the estimated cost of construction or development in respect of which property or the sale consideration of apartment unit which is yet be constructed of only this, the estimated cost need not be final cost. 

Suppose a developer pays stamp duty on the basis ofestimated cost of construction and at a later date for obvious reasons the project comes to a halt or reduced in size, there is no provision in the Act to claim refund of the excess stamp duty paid on estimated value of cost of construction in cases where the construction is reduced in size and full refundof stamp duty paid in cases where the project is abandoned. 

Therefore, as a welfare state, the Government may give a fresh look to the issue of levy of stamp duty on joint development agreements to save the property developers from this unpleasant situation.

Wednesday 5 February 2014

ABNORMAL UPWARD REVISION OF STAMP DUTY FOR AGREEMENTS TO SELL IN KARNATAKA


Recently, the Government of Karnataka has imposed stamp duty on agreements to sell at 0.25 [point two five] per cent. The revised rates are effective from 1st April, 2009. Thus, with this revision, the stamp dutypayable for an agreement to sell of the value of the property of Rs.50,00,000/- would be s.12,500/- whereas before this revision the optimum stamp duty payable was only Rs.200/-.

The present rate of stamp duty would heavily burden the purchasersof properties which is considered to be abnormal and unfair when compared to the stamp duty levied for such instruments in the neighboring States. In the State of Tamil Nadu, the stamp duty payable on agreement to sell is only Rs. 10/- irrespective of the amount of sale consideration. Therefore, the Government of Karnataka may reconsider this matter keeping in mind the sufferings encountered by the purchasers on account of global economic recession and revert back to the pre-revised pattern of levy of stamp duty on slab system with optimum levy of Rs.200/-.



Art. 5(e) - If the Agreement or Memorandum of an Agreement relating to sale of immovable property wherein part performance of the contract and possession of the property is not delivered stamp duty payable will be at 0.25 [ point two five] rupees for every one hundred rupees or part thereof on the market value equal to the amount of consideration.


Art. 5(t) - If the Agreement or Memorandum of an Agreement is relating to construction or development or sale of immovable property including a multi unit house or building or unit of apartment or flat etc., by a person having a stipulation that after construction or develop- ment, such property shall be held jointly or severally by that person and the owner or lessee, as the case may be, of such property, or that it shall be sold jointly or severally by them or that a part of it shall be held jointly or severally by them and the remaining portion part thereof shall be sold jointly or severally by them, the stamp duty payable in such cases will be at One rupee for every one hundred rupees or part thereof on the market value of the property or the estimatedcost of construction or proposed construction or development or proposeddevelopment of property as the case may be, or on the consideration for suchtransfer whichever is higher, provided that if proper stamp duty is paid on a power of attorney executed between the same parties in respect of the same property under Article 41(e), (ea) and (eb), then stamp duty under this article shall berupees two hundred.

Award 

Art.11 - In respect of any decision in writing by an arbitrator or umpire, not being an award directing a partition, on a reference made otherwise than by an order of the Court in the course of a suit, the stamp duty payable shall be as are levied for a deed of conveyance under article 20(1) on the amount or market value of the property which is the subject matter ofaward, whichever is higher.

Sale Deed 

Art.20 In respect of deed of conveyance, the stamp duty payable will be 6 per cent instead of7 112 per cent. In addition to this, thepurchaser shall have to pay surcharge and cess on the amount of stamp duty.


Art.22 In respect of counterpart or duplicate of any instruments, chargeable with duty and in respect of which the proper stamp duty has been paid (i) if the stamp duty with which the original instrument is chargeable does not exceed five hundred rupees, the stamp duty payable shall besame as payable on the original and in other cases the stamp duty payable shallbe rupees five hundred.
Thus, the maximum stamp duty payable in respect of counterpart or duplicate of any instrument will be five hundred only.


Art.28 In respect of Instrument of gift not being settlement or will or transfer where the donee is not a family member of the donor the Stamp duty payable shall be same as are payable to a conveyance deed. Where thedonee is a member of the family of the donor the Stamp Duty payable shall be Rupeesone thousand.



Art.30 In respect of Lease of immovable property including under lease, sub lease or agreement to let or sub let whereby such lease, the rent is fixed or fine or premium or money advanced or security deposit is paid or delivered.

(i) Where the lease is for a term not exceeding five years - the stamp duty payable shall be one rupee for every one hundred rupees or part thereof on the total amount of average annual rent and fine or premium or moneyadvanced or security deposit payable under such lease 

(ii) Where the lease is for a term exceeding five years butnot more than 10 years the stamp duty payable shall be two rupees for every hundred rupees or part thereof on the total amount of average annual rent and fine or premium or money advanced or security deposited.

(iii) Where the lease is for a term exceeding 10 years but not more than 30 years the stamp duty payable shall be four rupees for every hundred rupees or part thereof on the total amount of average annual rent and fineor premium or money advanced or security deposited.

(iv) Where the lease is for a term exceeding 30 years or does not purport to be for any definite term, the stamp duty payable shall be same as are payable for a conveyance deed under art.20( I).



Art.41 (e) - when power of attorney is given for consideration and or when coupled with interest and authorizing the attorney to sell any immovable property the stamp duty payable shall be same as are payable to a conveyance deed under article 20(1) on consideration or on market value of the property whichever is higher.

Art. 41(ea) - when given to a promoter or developer for construction or development or sale of immovable property including a multi-unit house or building or unit of apartment or flat etc., by a person having a stipulation that after construction or development, such property shall be heldjointly or severally by that person and the owner or lessee, as the case may be, of such property, or that it shall be sold jointly or severally by them or that a part of it shall be held jointly or severally by them and the remaining portion part thereof shall be sold jointly or severally by them, in such cases stamp duty payable will be at One rupee for every one hundred rupees or part thereof on the market value of the property or the estimated cost of construction orproposed construction or development or proposed development of property as thecase may be or on the consideration for such transfer whichever is higher.

Release deeds


The stamp duty payable shall be as are payable for a conveyance deed under Article 20(1) on the market value of the property or onthe amount or the value of the claim renounced or consideration for such releasewhichever is higher.